What Would it Take to Stop Individual Sex Trafficking Forever?
Please note: Fight the New Drug is really a non-religious and non-legislative awareness and education organization. Some of the issues discussed in the following article are legislatively-affiliated. Which includes links and discussions about these legislative matters does not constitute an endorsement by Fight the New Drug. Even though our organization is non-legislative, we fully support the legislation of already illegal forms of pornography and sexual exploitation, including the fight against sex trafficking.
Are you aware sex trafficking is a global industry?
This operates like a market along with supply, demand, and submission. As an example, we experience these types of basic economic principles whenever we go to the grocery stores that send out food, see the supply of fresh new produce farmers grow, and we as customers drive demand for products based on what we buy.
Obviously, we aren’t talking about vegetables and fruit when we talk about sex trafficking. In this illicit market, traffickers are the distribution, demand is certainly driven by sex customers, and the victims are the supply.
Think about that will for a moment. In human being trafficking, people are the products on sale. Not only is this illegal, it is also unethical because people are not products that can be bought or marketed.
Recently, all of us detailed and identified the people in the sex trafficking globe: the victims, traffickers, and buyers. We examined who they are and their motivations. At this point, we want to talk about solutions.
Associated: The Traffickers, Victims, And Buyers: Here is How Sex Trafficking Happens
For the complex social issue, we want a multi-faceted solution that includes protection, prosecution, and avoidance.
This means helping victims, bringing justice in order to traffickers, holding buyers accountable, and rejecting aspects of our culture that normalize exploitation. This really is easier said than done, but for the sake of victims, we are obligated to repay them our awareness and efforts to work toward a global that has conquered human captivity.
Defense: The victims
Identifying and rescuing victims is a crucial step, and the faster this happens, the better it is for a victim both mentally and physically. Removing sufferers from trafficking situations gets to be more complex once we realize that not all victims are physically controlled. This is a common myth associated with sex trafficking.
For years, the go-to strategy has been to remove victims in police raids. This method could be successful, but it often does not take into account the power dynamics in between traffickers and victims. Even as we mentioned, not all victims are usually waiting to be physically freed. Psychological manipulation or economic restraints can keep them tethered to their trafficker.
For these reasons, many organizations and advocates have moved far from the idea of victim “rescue. ” Simply removing them from your situation does not also recovery them from the trauma they have experienced.
Related: 5 Myths You’ve Probably Heard About Child Sex Trafficking
Even after a raid, some sufferers return to their trafficker. To the people of us who have never experienced sex trafficking, this may seem unbelievable. An organization that’s working to end child trafficking plus exploitation, Thorn, explained it this way:
“It may take 6-7 efforts to exit the Life before a permanent exit occurs. Preparing for the same reason it takes several exits for domestic assault victims—the emotional bond towards the trafficker. ”
When victims leave an exploitative situation, they require support, not a criminal record. This can include immediate shelter and basic necessities, mental health services, reintroducing practical everyday life activities, and seeking work. This last aspect can help survivors find the financial freedom they have to avoid re-trafficking.
Being sex trafficked is really a “lifetime cost” meaning we owe survivors support plus kindness well beyond their particular exit.
Related: 15 Stats You Need To Know In case you Care About Ending Child Sex Trafficking
Prosecution: The traffickers
Bringing proper rights to traffickers is a trial. The first step is to identify plus catch traffickers, which is the easier part. What is challenging is certainly successfully moving them through the criminal justice system plus convicting them of a sexual intercourse trafficking charge.
Not only is it difficult to collect proof to prove a case of sex trafficking beyond a reasonable doubt, but a confidence often requires the help of the victim. As you can imagine, there are comparable “he said, she said” issues like in sexual attack cases; however , the victim’s testimony is still important to secure.
One study reported that the most frequent problem law enforcement agencies faced to check into sex trafficking cases was “lack of victim assistance, ” which is a harsh way of saying they are afraid in order to participate. Paradoxically, it is often this fear that alerts law enforcement to the case in the first place. Above fear, a victim may not want to participate because sexual intercourse trafficking cases take a very long time, even more time than other criminal cases like labour trafficking.
Related: Who Are Sex Traffickers, Plus Why Do They Exploit Other Humans?
As an example, the infamous GirlsDoPorn case exactly where 22 women took porn producers to court with regard to sex trafficking them continues to be ongoing for about 4 yrs. Many of the women were sexual intercourse trafficked into performing in porn in 2015 and 2016, and while the city suit was settled, the particular criminal case against the porn producers for federal sex trafficking charges has not occurred yet.
If a victim does choose to participate, the defense will often try to undermine the victim’s testimony. Unfortunately, this can be performed because the victim may have the criminal record as a result of being trafficked, or their memory may be questioned because of their past trauma. Combine all of these challenges collectively and it can be further traumatizing to victims and may not really result in a conviction.
The alternative is reverse sting operations. For example , a female officer can pose undercover as a prostituted person on the street or online. She successfully attracts the interest of a “pimp” who begins to recruit her for trafficking purposes. In these operations, police force have clearly documented evidence of trafficking and the police officer has the capacity to give testimony in courtroom.
Related: Do you realize Men And Boys Can Be Victims Of Sex Trafficking, Too?
Drawback is that these operations need resources. They can make a dent, but there is little proof that going after traffickers arguements demand. Arrests and profitable prosecutions bring justice and could benefit victims, but it will never solve trafficking on its own.
Which brings us to what drives the demand: customers.
Criminal prosecution and Prevention: The buyers
If we could wave a magic wand and remove all victims from exploitation and justly punish all traffickers, everybody would take that option. But even if we could, trafficking would still return due to the demand. While there are still purchasers who want to purchase sex, you will see traffickers coercing victims.
Throughout history, keeping buyers accountable has mainly been left out of the sexual intercourse trafficking solution. This ends now.
We know there isn’t one single profile of a sex buyer. The majority are men, but those people men come from a variety of experience and express different motives. They do tend to be insensitive and much more likely to justify sex buying by saying things like, they are “just guys being guys” or “taking care of their needs, ” as opposed to non-buyers who are more likely to say that purchasing sex is exploitative plus treats females as items.
Clearly, buyers need better details, and there are programs that just this. One example is a one-day education course with regard to first time arrested sex purchasers in San Francisco.
Related: By The Numbers: Could be the Porn Industry Connected To Sexual intercourse Trafficking?
In 2008, researchers examined the effectiveness of the program by looking for the second arrest for intercourse buying in the ten years prior to the education program and ten years after. The researchers failed to expect the course to create lasting effects because it is hard to change a person’s behavior, but the results revealed the rearrest rate dropped by 40% after the education system began. It appears to be successful within changing buyer behaviors.
Addressing the need includes changing our considering. The old-school idea is that police should arrest intercourse workers to take them off the street, but this seems to do more harm compared to good. Focusing on demand requires a shift of resources to pay attention to the buyer.
Prevention: A cultural transformation
Prevention is frequently forgotten or ignored as part of the sex trafficking solution. Concentrating on buyers is one side from the story, but we also have to consider our culture that normalizes sex buying and exploitation.
You may be thinking, hold on, no one is in favor of sex trafficking. Just how can this be “normalized” in our society?
Related: Why Fighting Sex Trafficking Needs To Include Fighting Porno
Based on Eli Zucker, the Movie director of Men’s Accountability at a Seattle anti-trafficking nonprofit, sex buying is tied up in buyers’ understanding of what it means to be a man. From interacting with man sex buyers as a facilitator for a re-education program, Zucker noticed the messaging about masculinity is holding them back. Some of those messages are that men should be excessively sexual, dominant, and consistently ready for sex with lots of different women. Men learn earlier that they should be aggressive plus unemotional.
“In this brand of masculinity, failure is inevitable. It really is here, in this impossible yet inevitable corner, that men often develop violent plus unhealthy behaviors, like intercourse buying or using pornography, to meet the unachievable requirements of this specific version of masculinity. ”
Clearly these particular messages of how a man “should be” aren’t serving men and definitely not victims. Yet these messages are loud and very clear in pornography.
Related: How To Identify Sexual intercourse Trafficking Victims And Stop Adding to Sexual Exploitation
The online porn planet breeds a strong sense associated with sexual entitlement that normalizes sex buying behaviors. We all see this when customers say they believe intercourse buying is harmless thrilling that the women are stimulated in that industry. We listen to similar excuses in the world of porn material, too.
Maybe we should be asking ourselves, why do some of our culture’s tips of “fun” involve objectication?
Obviously, intercourse trafficking existed before web pornography, so we can’t say it is the sole cause, yet research continually shows that porno is directly connected to encouraging the demand for intercourse trafficking.
Clicking on, downloading, and consuming porno sends the message that our society accepts exploitation just for “fun. ” But we are able to counter that message with the actions. People aren’t products and bodies aren’t commodities, let us not treat them this way.
The post What Would it Take to Stop Individual Sex Trafficking Forever? appeared first on Fight the New Drug.